Should You Grade Your Sports Cards? Here’s How to Decide
Grading your sports cards can be a great way to increase their value, especially if you’re planning to sell or display them. But not every card is worth the investment. In this blog, we’ll break down the pros and cons of card grading, how it works, and when it makes the most sense.
What Is Card Grading?
Card grading is the process of having a third-party company—like PSA, BGS, or SGC—professionally evaluate the condition of your trading card. They assign it a score (usually 1 to 10), which can dramatically affect the card’s market value.
Top 3 Reasons to Grade Your Sports Cards
1. Boost Value for Sale or Trade
A graded card often sells for 2x–10x more than its raw (ungraded) counterpart—especially if it scores a PSA 9 or PSA 10.
2. Protect and Authenticate
Grading adds a layer of protection with a tamper-proof case, and it certifies the card’s authenticity—important for high-value or vintage cards.
3. Make Your Collection Stand Out
For collectors, a row of slabbed cards not only looks impressive but also adds legitimacy to your collection.
When NOT to Grade a Card
- Modern base cards with little resale value
- Cards with visible damage or centering issues
- Cards that sell for under $50 even in top condition
Instead, focus on rookies, autos, numbered inserts, or vintage cards with potential.
What Cards Are Worth Grading?
Here are a few types of cards that are usually worth grading:
- Rookie cards of star players (e.g., Caleb Williams, Elly De La Cruz)
- Low-numbered parallels or short prints
- Autographed cards
- Vintage cards (especially pre-1990) in decent condition
Use tools like eBay’s “Sold Listings” or market apps like Card Ladder to estimate value.
How Much Does It Cost?
Grading prices vary, but here’s a quick breakdown (as of 2025):
- PSA Value Bulk: ~$20–25 per card
- SGC Standard: ~$15–18
- BGS: ~$22–35+
Some companies offer economy tiers with longer turnaround times but cheaper rates.
Final Thoughts: Grade or Not?
If you’re holding a raw card with potential—especially rookies or numbered inserts—grading could be a game-changer. Just be sure to check comps and inspect condition before sending them in.